Commission’s proposed TACs for 2020

Ahead of the 16-17 December Council meeting on Fisheries, the Commission has adopted its proposal for fishing opportunities in 2020 for 72 stocks in the Atlantic and the North Sea: for 32 stocks the fishing quota is either increased or remains the same; for 40 stocks the quota is reduced.

Karmenu Vella, Commissioner for Environment, Maritime Affairs and Fisheries, said: “Today’s proposal consolidates our efforts for sustainable fishing in Atlantic and North Sea waters. Over the past years, we have had a steady rise in the number of healthy stocks, and – as a consequence – also a steady rise in the profits of our fishing sector. This is the result of responsible management and continuous implementation efforts, primarily by our fishermen, who are the first ones to implement our conservation measures and also the ones to benefit most from increased yields. With such sustained commitment, 2020 will be another year of progress for Europe’s fisheries.”

In line with the objectives and legal framework of the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP), the Commission is proposing fishing opportunities at “maximum sustainable yield” (MSY) for the stocks with a full scientific assessment, and at “precautionary levels” for other stocks. The proposal follows the advice of the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES).

Currently, 59 stocks are being fished at MSY, up from 9 in 2009. This means that the fishing pressure on the stocks is limited to a level that will allow a healthy future for the fish stocks’ biomass, while taking into account socio-economic factors. The Commission says it is working with Member States to support the fishermen in reaching the objective of fishing all stocks at sustainable levels by 2020, as set by the Common Fisheries Policy. As the size of some key fish stocks is increasing – for instance, Haddock in the Celtic Sea and Sole in the Bristol Channel– so has the profitability of the fishing sector, with an estimated €1.3 billion gross profit for 2019.

The proposal will now be submitted for discussion and decision by the EU Member States at the Fisheries Council on 16-17 December in Brussels, to be applied as of 1 January 2020.

Details of the proposal

For 2020, the multiannual plans for the North Sea and for the Western Waters provide the framework to adapt management measures to complex mixed fisheries as well as to avoid extreme variations of TACs. For instance:

The Commission proposes to limit the decrease of the TACs for Northern and Southern Hake to -20%, using the upper part of the MSY range according to the Western Waters multiannual plan. The stocks have a healthy biomass, therefore a limited reduction of the fishing pressure would suffice to keep the stocks in good shape, according to scientists.

The TAC for Haddock in the Celtic Sea could increase massively according to ICES advice (+100%), but the Commission proposes a 30% increase, using the lower part of the MSY range, in order to protect the vulnerable cod stock that is caught as a bycatch of haddock.

Where multiannual plans are not in place, the Commission has turned to the management strategies of the Advisory Councils, which have been assessed by ICES as sustainable. For example, for the southern Horse Mackerel, the Commission has proposed to follow the management strategy of the Pelagic Advisory Council, which recommends a reduction of the quota by 50%.

The Commission has also proposed safeguard measures to ensure that the amount of Cod and Whiting in the Celtic Sea recovers to safe levels. These measures consist of increased selectivity, closures and appropriate control to prevent discards.

The Commission proposes to continue the quota exchange system for the by-catches. These are quotas set for stocks fished as by-catches in other healthy target fisheries. This system ensures that Member States with no quota for one of these by-catch stocks can continue fishing for other target stocks. The exact amounts for the by-catch TACs and their accompanying measures will be issued at a later stage, after ICES provides its scientific advice.

Since 1 January 2019, the landing obligation applies to EU fishing fleets: all catches of regulated commercial species (including by-catch) must be landed and counted against each Member State’s quota. In the proposal, the Commission has already deducted from the advised catches the amounts corresponding to the agreed exemptions to the landing obligation.

Table 1: Stocks with proposals for increased Total Allowable Catch (TAC)

Table 2: Stocks with no changes in Total Allowable Catch (TAC)

Common name	Scientific name	TAC Unit	Final TAC in 2019	TAC 2020 (Proposal)
Common sole	Solea	6; Union and international waters of 5b; international waters of 12 and 14	57	57
Common sole	Solea	7b and 7c	42	42
Greater silver smelt	Argentina silus	Union and international waters of 1 and 2	90	90
Greater silver smelt	Argentina silus	Union waters of 3a and 4	1234	1234
Herring	Clupea harengus	7e and 7f	930	930
Ling	Molva molva	3a	170	170
Ling	Molva molva	Union and international waters of 1 and 2	36	36
Ling	Molva molva	Union and international waters of 5	33	33
Ling	Molva molva	Union and international waters of 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12 and 14	20396	20396
Ling	Molva molva	Union waters of 4	4035	4035
Norway lobster	Nephrops	8c	3	3
Norway lobster	Nephrops	3a	13733	13733
Plaice	Pleuronectes platessa	6; Union and international waters of 5b; international waters of 12 and 14	658	658
Plaice	Pleuronectes platessa	7b and 7c	74	74
Saithe	Pollachius virens	7, 8, 9 and 10; Union waters of CECAF 34.1.1	3176	3176
Tusk	Brosme brosme	3a	31	31
Tusk	Brosme brosme	Union and international waters of 1, 2 and 14	21	21
Tusk	Brosme brosme	Union and international waters of 5, 6 and 7	4130	4130
Tusk	Brosme brosme	Union waters of 4	251	251

Table 3: Stocks with proposals for decreased Total Allowable Catch (TAC)

Table 4: Stocks for which the Total Allowable Catch (TAC) is delegated to an individual Member State