Advertise Subscribe
BIM FLAG Southwest: You've got the idea. We've got the funding. Let's talk. Application workshop, Rose Hotel Tralee, 25 November 2026
BIM FLAG Southwest: You've got the idea. We've got the funding. Let's talk. Application workshop, Rose Hotel Tralee, 25 November 2026

News Hub / Ireland

A Vision for 2040, but No New Deal for Ireland Yet

Share this article
Minister of State Timmy Dooley, Taoiseach Micheál Martin and EU Fisheries Commissioner Costas Kadis answer The Skipper's question on reforming the Common Fisheries Policy at the opening of European Maritime Day in Cork in May 2025. Photo: The Skipper

Minister of State Timmy Dooley, Taoiseach ⁠​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​‌​​​‌​‌​​‌​​‌​‌‌‌​‌‌⁠Micheál Martin and EU Fisheries Commissioner Costas Kadis answer The Skipper’s question on reforming the Common Fisheries Policy at the opening of European Maritime Day in Cork in May 2025. Photo: The Skipper

On 20 October the European Commission published its Vision 2040 for fisheries and aquaculture, the 15-year plan Fisheries Commissioner Costas Kadis promised when he took office. What it did not bring was a commitment to rewrite the Common Fisheries Policy.

For the Irish fleet, that is the question that matters. Since December 2025, when the Hague Preferences were blocked for the first time in almost half a century, and with the Brexit transfers still biting, the Government, the producer organisations and the Oireachtas fisheries committee have all said the CFP has to change. Minister of State Timmy Dooley told The Skipper’s Lorna Siggins, in an interview in Castletownbere in July, that by the end of Ireland’s EU Presidency he would like to see “an appreciation that the CFP is no longer fit for purpose”, shared by enough member states to make a difference. So where does the Irish case stand, and what is Brussels planning?

The Irish Case

Ireland’s complaint runs deeper than any of the priorities in the Vision, and it begins with relative stability. When the first CFP quotas were shared out in 1983, each country’s percentage was based on its catches in the years 1973 to 1978, not on the waters around it. Ireland’s fleet was small then, and the shares have stayed largely fixed since. Sinn Féin TD Conor McGuinness, chair of the Oireachtas fisheries committee, told Mr Kadis in Cork in July that the policy “is manifestly unjust to Ireland”, pointing out that Belgium, with a coastline shorter than County Waterford’s, has larger quotas for some species in Irish waters than the entire Irish fleet. At the same Cork meeting, Agence Europe reported, Mr Dooley told fellow ministers the policy now needed “a very substantial revision”, and that founding principles including relative stability were “no longer suited” to a sea where stocks are moving north.

Brexit made the imbalance worse. Under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, the Irish Fish Producers Organisation (IFPO) says, Ireland supplied 40% of the total value of fish transferred to the UK. The Hague Preferences, the 1970s arrangement that topped up Irish quotas when stocks fell, were the last safeguard. When they were blocked last December, Ireland’s 2026 quotas fell by more than 50,000 tonnes. John Lynch, chief executive of the Irish South and East Fish Producers Organisation (IS&EFPO), told EU ministers in Cork that the loss turned 20% quota cuts into real losses of 40 to 50% for Irish boats. “When you say the words Common Fisheries Policy to an Irish fisherman, he does not hear the word common,” he said.

The Seafood Ireland Alliance, which speaks for four of Ireland’s six producer organisations and the processors, took the point further at the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Fisheries and Maritime Affairs on 20 October. Since Brexit, it said, the big quota decisions are made between the Commission and third countries, the regionalisation built into the CFP has faded and member states and the industry “have become peripheral”, leaving the December Council as “nothing more than a ‘rubber stamping’ exercise”. It put the Hague Preferences at 12,740 tonnes for Ireland in 2027, including 10,655 tonnes of mackerel, and asked the Government not to accept any outcome in which they are set aside without equivalent compensation.

Nor is change easy to win. Quota keys can be altered only by a qualified majority of member states, and any gain for Ireland is a loss for someone else. Kieran Mulvey, in his July report to Mr Dooley, said he did not believe the sharing system would be reopened, and advised the industry to concentrate on “what is achievable”. The IFPO’s chief executive, Aodh O’Donnell, sees it differently. After Brussels signalled it could be flexible on fisheries to bring Iceland back to the table, he said: “If the European Commission was ready to accept that the CFP cannot work for Iceland, then it must also acknowledge that the CFP is not working for Ireland.”

Capacity is the second Irish problem, and here the Vision does at least open a door. Ireland’s capacity ceiling was set in 2014 at 77,568 gross tonnes and 210,083 kW. At the end of 2023 the fleet stood at 58,003 gross tonnes and 162,177 kW, according to the State’s annual fleet report to the Commission. So the national ceiling is not the immediate obstacle. The entry and exit rule is: every new vessel must be matched by at least the same capacity withdrawn, without public aid, from the same fleet segment, and capacity scrapped under decommissioning is gone for good. A bigger, safer hull, or the extra weight of batteries, hybrid drives or alternative fuels, means buying tonnage. Mr Dooley made the point in his interview with The Skipper: a boat that could also work as a wellboat for fish farms would need a higher kilowatt rating that “would be prevented currently”. It is, he said, “not about increasing the catching capacity of the fleet”. The European Parliament has called the ceilings an obstacle to the energy transition. The environmental group Seas At Risk disagrees: a study it published in September found the EU fleet can decarbonise within the existing ceilings. The Vision’s plan to define “effective harvesting capacity” could help Irish owners, but only if it reaches the entry and exit rules that bind them.

The landing obligation is the third. At Rockall, the scientific advice allows 23,000 tonnes of haddock but only 9 tonnes of cod as bycatch. “This is an absurd situation,” Mr Lynch told ministers in Cork. Europêche, which speaks for fishing enterprises across the EU, sent the Commission its own proposal for a workable landing obligation on 1 October, with more flexibility for mixed fisheries and choke situations, where running out of quota for one species can tie up a boat that still has quota for others. The European Association of Fish Producers Organisations (EAPO), whose members include Irish producer organisations, wants a complete revision that keeps the rule’s objective.

Then there are the people. Mr Mulvey found that most Irish boat owners are aged between 50 and 70, and that most inshore boats are 25 to 35 years old. Patrick Murphy of the Irish South and West Fish Producers Organisation (IS&WFPO) told RTÉ that “it’s very hard to entice new, young people into the industry”. Mr Lynch put it more personally: his son, who co-skippers the family boat, keeps asking whether there is a future in fishing, and will invest in a boat of his own only if someone can show him a return. The generational renewal strategy the Vision promises for 2027 will be judged against that question.

What Brussels Has Put On The Table

The Vision is a strategy, not a law. It sets priorities for the sector to 2040, covering healthy ecosystems, the energy transition, supply and demand, access to finance and the EU’s fleets abroad, and it asks member states to turn them into national measures. Mr Kadis described it as a vision “backed by concrete initiatives to get us there”.

On the issues that matter most to Irish skippers, the commitments are these. On the landing obligation, the Commission accepts that the rule has not delivered, notably in the way it has been applied, and will hold a dialogue with the industry later this year before looking at new technology and fuller catch documentation. On the fleet, it will update its 2014 guidelines on balancing fishing capacity with fishing opportunities, and will consider how to define “effective harvesting capacity” separately from capacity needed for safety, crew conditions or cleaner engines. A Blue Generational Renewal Strategy is promised for 2027 and an aquaculture proposal by the end of 2027. Small-scale fishermen are to get dedicated provisions in the Ocean Act, now expected early in 2027.

The money points to the next EU budget, for 2028 to 2034, where the Commission has proposed a minimum of €2 billion ring-fenced for core fisheries policy within national and regional plans. EAPO said on 21 October that its members consider that figure “far too low” compared with the current European Maritime, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund.

What the Vision does not do is announce ⁠​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​‌​​​‌​‌​​‌​​‌​‌‌‌​‌‌⁠a revision of the CFP Regulation itself. The Commission’s own question-and-answer note says it “will seek to improve the existing legal framework” and bring forward targeted initiatives. Agence Europe reported that Mr Kadis acknowledged the document did not rule out legislative proposals. There is no mention of relative stability, the key that fixes each country’s share of each quota.

It is not what Ireland was promised. Irish ministers have pushed for change at every turn, and The Skipper has put the CFP reform question to Mr Kadis three times in 14 months. Each time the answer was that Ireland’s concerns would shape the reform.

At the opening of European Maritime Day in Cork in May 2025, we asked him and Taoiseach Micheál Martin whether it was time to look again at how Ireland is treated under the CFP. Mr Kadis said the views of Irish fishermen would be “taken into consideration to address any weaknesses of the common fisheries policy and make the targeted interventions that are required”. The Taoiseach accepted it was “challenging to reopen the entirety of that agreement” with 27 member states, but said the Government would be “pursuing further additionality in terms of our quota” and would take the issue up with the Commissioner.

Skipper Editor Niall Duffy (right) talks to EU Fisheries Commissioner Costas Kadis (left) and Minister of State Timmy Dooley during the Commissioner’s visit to Castletownbere in May 2025. Photo: Anne Marie Cronin Photography
Skipper Editor Niall Duffy (right) talks to EU Fisheries Commissioner Costas Kadis (left) and Minister of State Timmy Dooley during the Commissioner’s visit to Castletownbere in May 2025. Photo: Anne Marie Cronin Photography

The next day in Castletownbere, where he sat down for an interview with The Skipper’s Lorna Siggins, Skipper Editor Niall Duffy asked him whether relative stability and equal access, the two pillars the CFP was built on 50 years ago, should be adjusted now that warming waters are moving stocks, leaving Ireland with species it has no quota for and quota for species that have left. That, he said, was why the Commission was evaluating the CFP: to look at “what is the new situation on the ground and what are the emerging challenges”, and whether the CFP as it stands is fit for purpose. It would “address any weaknesses” and “definitely” take into consideration “the impacts of climate change, the distribution of stocks”. He would not prejudge the outcome, “but what I can assure you is that we will take into account the positions of the fisheries sector in Ireland, and that’s why I’m here today.”

In Cork this July, when we asked him whether the CFP had failed Ireland, yes or no, he replied that the policy had produced “tangible, positive results” for stocks, but added: “We expected better results. And also, the socioeconomic indicators are not the expected ones.” The blocking of the Hague Preferences, he said, was “a decision by the member states, which is not directly connected to the CFP”. He acknowledged that “the Irish sector faces specific challenges, especially after Brexit”, and said: “If there will be a targeted amendment of the Common Fisheries Policy Regulation, this amendment will also take into consideration the challenges of the Irish sector.” Generational renewal, simplification, fleet modernisation and a fair deal for small-scale fishermen, he told another reporter, would “definitely” be in “the note that I will present to the College of Commissioners for a possible targeted amendment of the Common Fisheries Policy Regulation.” Three times in 14 months, Ireland was told its concerns would be built into a reform. Dublin has kept pushing, from the Taoiseach’s quota demands to Mr Dooley’s call in Cork for a substantial revision. Brussels has not bent: three months after Mr Kadis’s last assurance, the Vision contains no such amendment.

The reaction split along familiar lines. Europêche, which speaks for fishing enterprises, issued a joint statement on the day with the European Transport Workers’ Federation (ETF), the food and farm workers’ federation EFFAT and the farm and co-operative body Copa-Cogeca, headed “Commission’s Vision leaves EU fisheries and aquaculture at a dead end”. They point out that the CFP was last reformed in 2013, more than three years past its usual ten-year cycle, and that without a revision the current rules are set to stay in place until 2040, 27 years after they were adopted. Europêche’s president, Javier Garat, was blunt: “A Vision without CFP revision is a dead letter and, without concrete measures, an empty gesture.” He added: “No fisherman is proud of the current CFP.” The ETF welcomed one concrete step, a commitment to bring the STCW-F safety training standards for fishing crews into EU law by spring 2028, but said the few actions proposed would not improve working conditions, safety or the appeal of fishing jobs. The four bodies also regretted that the Vision only mentions, without committing to, extending consumer information rules to prepared and preserved seafood.

The next day the producer organisations’ European body, EAPO, made the same case. It welcomed the Commission’s diagnosis but regretted that the Vision does not commit to revising the CFP, offering a dialogue on the landing obligation instead of a proposal and putting off until 2027 the question of how fishing capacity is measured. “A fleet whose average age is close to 40 years cannot modernise on announcements,” it said. Its president, Jean-Marie Robert, called for “a targeted revision of the CFP with a clear timetable”, backed by a budget to match.

Seas At Risk and Low Impact Fishers of Europe, by contrast, welcomed the focus on applying the current rules rather than reopening them. “The CFP already provides the tools we need; what is missing is the political will to use them fully,” said Seas At Risk’s executive director, Monica Verbeek.

The calendar now points to a collision. On 17 September the European Parliament voted by 368 to 172, with 69 abstentions, for a resolution calling for a revision of the CFP, including a review of the landing obligation. It asked the Commission for a simplification package before the end of 2026 and warned that, if no concrete legislative proposals arrive by then, it may draw up its own legislative initiative report under Article 225 of the Treaty, formally asking the Commission to act. That deadline falls in the last weeks of Ireland’s Council Presidency.

What The Evaluation Found

The Vision rests on the Commission’s evaluation of the CFP Regulation, published on 30 April 2026 and covering 2014 to 2024. Its verdict was mixed. The share of stocks fished at sustainable levels rose from 50% in 2014 to 63% in 2022, but the goal of fishing all stocks sustainably was missed, and stocks have not grown back as expected. The economic gains promised by the 2013 reform did not arrive, with an ageing fleet, high energy dependency and difficult generational renewal all named as reasons. The landing obligation, the evaluation found, had not led to the expected improvements in fishing practice or selectivity, mainly because of poor implementation.

The Commission’s central conclusion was that the main problem lies less in the rules than in uneven implementation and enforcement across member states, and its question-and-answer note calls the CFP “a solid framework” for long-term environmental sustainability. Environmental groups read that as a reason to leave the regulation alone. The catching sector reads it the other way: a policy that needs this much fixing in practice needs fixing in law.

Who Wants What, And Where Ireland Fits

In September the European Parliament’s research service published a briefing setting out the positions ahead of the Vision. Europêche questioned whether a new vision was needed at all and called instead for an omnibus fisheries proposal to cut red tape and fix contradictions between laws. A group led by Low Impact Fishers of Europe and Seas At Risk called for a shift from an industrial model to what it calls a regenerative and equitable one. Fish farmers’ federation FEAP wants a dedicated aquaculture policy, ClientEarth puts healthy stocks first, and the research institutes’ body EFARO warns that cuts to data funding would weaken the science. The Parliament’s 2024 resolution called for a review of the landing obligation to deal with choke species, and described fleet capacity ceilings as an obstacle to the energy transition.

Only one member state is profiled: Spain, which the briefing explains has the largest catch and the largest workforce in the EU. Madrid wants simpler rules, stronger science, a level playing field with third countries and explicit funding: reasonable aims, but a big fishing nation’s aims. Ireland, which holds the Council Presidency, which says it carried 40% of the value of the EU’s Brexit transfers and whose fleet still lives with the 1983 key, does not appear at all. That is a choice of method rather than a slight, but it shows how easily the Irish case drops out of the Brussels conversation unless Ireland puts it there.

Ireland has the chair until the end of December, a Minister of State who says the CFP is no longer fit for purpose, and a Parliament deadline that falls on its watch. Mr Lynch offered ministers in Cork a test for whatever comes next. “For many fishermen the CFP was written for yesterday,” he said. “It must become a document written for tomorrow.” Whether the next CFP is written with Ireland in the room, or around it, will be settled over the coming year.

The road to a new CFP

WhenWhat
1983Quota key fixed (relative stability)
Jan 2024Parliament sets out CFP views
Dec 2025Hague Preferences blocked
30 Apr 2026CFP evaluation published
1 Jul 2026Ireland takes EU Presidency
29 Jul 2026Ministers meet in Cork
17 Sep 2026Parliament votes for revision
20 Oct 2026Vision 2040 adopted
Late 2026Landing obligation dialogue
End 2026Parliament deadline
Early 2027Ocean Act due
2027Generational renewal strategy
End 2027Aquaculture proposal
2028New EU budget period begins

Read more: CFP Is No Longer Fit for Purpose! Minister Dooley

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Please enter a comment.
Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email address.

The Skipper Windy Map
The Skipper Tide Checker

Loading tide data...

The Skipper Weather Station

Loading weather data...