Advertise Subscribe
BIM FLAG an Iardheiscirt: Is agatsa atá an smaoineamh. Is againne atá an cistiú. Labhraímis. Ceardlann iarratais, Óstán an Róis, Trá Lí, 25 Samhain 2026
BIM FLAG an Iardheiscirt: Is agatsa atá an smaoineamh. Is againne atá an cistiú. Labhraímis. Ceardlann iarratais, Óstán an Róis, Trá Lí, 25 Samhain 2026

News Hub / Ireland

Mulvey Report Lands: Fishermen Say There’s Nothing New

Share this article
-4

The long-awaited report by Kieran Mulvey ⁠​​​​​​​‌‌​‌​‌‌​‌​‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​‌‌‌​‌​⁠to Minister of State Timmy Dooley T.D. on the Irish seafood industry has finally come out. Titled a review of the concerns of the Seafood/Fishery Sector, it runs to 14 recommendations and dozens of pages of background. But the reaction from fishermen who spoke to The Skipper is a familiar one: they say they’ve heard it all before.

Mulvey was asked by Minister Dooley to visit the country’s main fishing harbours and hear directly from the people working in them. Between February and April 2026, he travelled to Killybegs, Dingle, Castletownbere, Ros a Mhil, Dunmore East (also taking in Kilmore Quay and Wexford), and Howth (with input from Clogherhead). He also held online meetings with groups including the Irish Islands Marine Resource Organisation and co-operatives from Killybegs, Foyle, Castletownbere and Clogherhead.

In total he heard from a long list of bodies: the Irish Fish Producers Organisation, the Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation, the National Inshore Fishermen’s Association, ISEFPO, ISWFPO, NRIFF, NIFF, SERIFF, SWRIFF, the Clogherhead Fishermen’s Co-Operative, IFPEA and Donegal Fish, along with a written submission on the bottom mussel industry. He also met the IFA’s aquaculture representatives, BIM, the Marine Institute, and the SFPA.

He was clear about the value of doing it this way. Meeting people at their own piers, he wrote, gave him “an ‘on the spot’ experience of the geographical area within which they operate,” and he thanked fishermen for their “frank and constructive exchanges” and follow-up written submissions.

 

Kieran Mulvery Report On Seafood & Fishery Sector 1

Why Now

The backdrop to the report is a sector under real strain. Irish fishing quotas for 2026 are down 51,000 tonnes on 2025, after EU countries blocked a deal called the Hague Preferences at Council level last December. That single decision, more than anything else, set the tone for what Mulvey heard at every harbour.

The report also lands at a moment of change. Ireland takes over the Presidency of the EU Council in July 2026, putting the country in a position to help shape the next steps on fisheries policy, including a long-term “Vision 2040” for fisheries and fish farming across the EU. The European Commission published its own review of the Common Fisheries Policy in May 2026, and that review is expected to be a major talking point during Ireland’s term running the Council.

Mulvey also points to wider pressures that go beyond quotas: food security, climate change reshaping the seas faster than ever before, the growth of fish farming, offshore wind farms competing for sea space, and marine protected areas limiting where boats can fish. All of these, he says, will need serious policy attention over the next ten years, and will require what he calls “a deeper integrated approach across Ministers, Departments and Agencies.”

The Numbers Behind the Sector

The report gives a useful snapshot of the industry’s scale. Direct employment stands at 9,996: 2,681 people fishing, 1,908 in fish farming, and 3,407 in processing, spread across more than 2,000 fishing boats. Counting indirect jobs, total employment tied to the sector is close to 17,000, compared with 169,000 in farming.

Ireland’s main export markets for fish are France, the UK, Italy, Spain, Poland, China, Nigeria, the Netherlands, Japan and Germany. The whole sector is worth €1.24 billion, split between fishing (€461m), fish farming (€211m) and processing (€947m), figures drawn from BIM’s Business of Food 2024 report. Export values rose 9 percent in 2025 to €635 million, though Bord Bia’s own report flagged rising competition and price pressure from cheaper fish coming into Ireland’s main markets.

On the money side, the fishing part of the Department of Agriculture’s budget comes to €177 million out of a total department budget of €2.1 billion. Three agencies do most of the spending here: BIM gets €47 million, the SFPA €25 million, and the Marine Institute €43 million. Most grant schemes for the sector run through the Seafood Development Programme 2021-2027, worth €258 million and co-funded by the EU. On top of that, up to €308 million has been set aside under the Brexit Adjustment Reserve.

Old Problems, Old Answers

The report leans heavily on work that already exists. It draws on the Common Fisheries Policy Review Group reports from 2021 and 2022, BIM’s seafood figures, and a review of fish farm licensing carried out back in 2017. That 2017 review said the licensing system needed “a root and branch reform,” and Mulvey repeats that exact line in his own report, nine years later, more or less unchanged.

Even Mulvey seems to know how this looks. He records that people at every harbour told him the current system of working groups and forums produces no real results, with the same people turning up to the same meetings saying the same things. His answer, mostly, is to keep the meetings going but put a strict time limit and clear goals on each one, what he calls “sunset clauses.”

He also takes time in the report to walk through the history of how Ireland ended up with its current share of EU fishing quotas, stretching back to talks in 1970 and Ireland’s accession to the EEC in 1973. Quotas themselves were not set until the first Common Fisheries Policy in 1983, and the shares handed out then were based on each country’s average catch over past years rather than the size of its waters, a point Mulvey says has left Irish fishermen feeling short-changed ever since.

His conclusion on all this is blunt: he does not believe the EU’s quota-sharing system is going to be reopened or changed. His advice to fishermen is to stop spending energy trying to undo history and instead focus on “what is achievable,” warning against chasing issues that lead down what he calls a “Cul de Sac.”

The 14 Recommendations, in Full

Mulvey’s recommendations range from big structural change to small fixes to how paperwork is handled. Here is the full list, in plain terms.

#RecommendationWhat it means
1New Department of the MarineSplit fisheries out of Agriculture into its own government department
2Tidy up the lawSimplify the large pile of EU and Irish rules the sector must follow
3Handing down boatsHelp older skippers retire and pass boats to younger fishermen, keep the Young Skipper Scheme going
4Boat grantsMore grant money for boat repairs, safety gear, and modern onboard equipment
5Help for processorsMore support from Enterprise Ireland to help fish plants modernise and use new technology
6Work permitsA central list to speed up hiring crew from outside the EU
7Cut down on meetingsScrap talking groups that produce nothing, keep the useful ones, add firm deadlines
8Yearly income top-upA payment to make up for days lost to bad weather, quota limits, or other rules outside a fisherman’s control
9Simpler grant formsMake grant applications faster and less bureaucratic, with a fast-track for bigger awards
10Fix fish farm licensingSpeed up the slow licensing system holding back salmon, oyster and mussel farms
11Better marketingBord Bia to do more to sell Irish seafood in shops, restaurants and abroad, including direct marketing grants for industry groups
12One voice for the industryMerge the many separate fishing groups into a single national body with sub-committees
13Fund industry groupsState money to help fishing groups pay staff and cover running costs
14Other issuesCovers landing access in bad weather, shares of mackerel and herring quota, Bluefin Tuna fishing rights, and reform of how the SFPA enforces the rules

 

A Closer Look at the Big Ones

The call for a standalone Department of the Marine is the most eye-catching item on the list. Mulvey says it was “clearly evident” to him at every meeting that fisheries needs its own department, separate from Agriculture, to properly deal with the growing scope of ocean governance, sea-space planning, and international commitments.

On succession, the report notes that most boat owners are aged 50 to 70, and many told Mulvey they want to retire but see no clear path to hand the business on. He wants a new scheme, similar to ones already used in farming, to help with that handover, alongside free training courses for anyone taking on a boat. As of December 2023, the inshore fleet register carried 1,966 vessels under 15 metres, the boats that land most of the country’s crab, lobster, shrimp, whelk and razor clams.

The fleet itself is ageing badly. BIM figures cited in the report show most inshore boats are between 25 and 35 years old. Fuel, wages, insurance, tackle, and repair costs are all rising, and boats also need ongoing spend on shore-side facilities like freezers, ice supply and loading boxes just to keep catches usable. Mulvey notes that co-ops have raised the question of compensation in the past, pointing to previous payments under the Brexit Adjustment Reserve, and flags that the country’s four remaining co-ops are in a financially precarious position.

On crew shortages, Mulvey points to a genuinely tough sell: physically hard work, unsocial hours, and unpredictable schedules. His answer is a central register of EU and non-EU workers, alongside a standard employment contract, developed together with the Workplace Relations Commission and the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment.

On the yearly income top-up, Mulvey acknowledges the idea sits outside his own department’s control, since it touches on Revenue and Social Protection. He notes that fishermen currently qualify for a tax credit of €1,720 if they spend at least 80 days at sea, and suggests a wider scheme is needed to cover days lost through no fault of their own, whether from weather, closed grounds, or quota limits.

Fish Processing and Marketing

Processing is the single largest employer ⁠​​​​​​​‌‌​‌​‌‌​‌​‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​‌‌‌​‌​⁠in the sector, running across 101 plants nationwide covering pelagic, whitefish and shellfish species. Mulvey says capital investment here will be critical, and wants Enterprise Ireland to take a bigger role helping the larger processing firms access new technology and AI tools, an area he says is currently underused.

On marketing, the report credits Bord Bia with doing a broadly good job but says more could be done to push Irish seafood in supermarkets, restaurants and at food festivals. Industry representatives told Mulvey they would like to see Bord Bia offer direct marketing grants to representative bodies for events promoting specific fish species. On the export side, Irish fish sales to China reached €35 million in 2025, and a recent visit by An Taoiseach along with Bord Bia is expected to help push that figure further.

Mulvey also flags a longer-term funding worry. Post-2027, the EU’s fisheries funding is moving to a new Multiannual Financial Framework, and the early signals point to a real risk of reduced funding from the European Marine, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund, the main pipeline for grant schemes across the sector.

Fish Farming: Growth Held Back by Licensing

Fish farming is one part of the report where Mulvey sees real upside. The sector was worth €211 million in 2024, up 24 percent on the year before, driven mainly by salmon and Irish rock oysters, with jobs standing at roughly 1,900. He believes it has “enormous growth” potential and should get greater investment focus from government.

The problem, as Mulvey lays it out, is entirely the licensing system. Over 500 new and renewal applications are still sitting with the Department. He compares this unfavourably to Scotland’s system for salmon farming, which he says moves faster from application to decision, putting Irish producers and outside investors at a real disadvantage. New rules around marine protected areas and habitat directives are also squeezing the amount of sea space available for expansion.

Oyster farming gets particular attention. The sector is worth €49 million, built historically on standard oysters sold into France, a market Mulvey says has “largely collapsed.” In its place there is growing demand for the higher-value Irish “Speciale” oyster, but producers say licensing delays are stopping them investing in the new equipment needed to meet that demand. Worse, operators inside protected areas can’t access EU grant funding available to their competitors elsewhere in Europe even while their licence renewal drags on, a bind Mulvey calls a “classic ‘catch 22’ dilemma.” Since 2022, 24 permissions for new and experimental equipment have been granted under a specific legal provision, but Mulvey says the broader system still needs the “root and branch reform” first flagged back in 2017.

The Department’s AQUAMIS system is helping track applications, and a second phase allowing licence applications to be submitted online is still being built out.

A Fragmented Industry

One theme running through the report is how scattered the industry’s own representation is. Mulvey counts a long list of national and regional bodies, each with strong local roots tied to specific harbours, processing plants and fish stocks, but no single voice speaking for the sector as a whole.

His recommendation is for the various national groups to consider forming one umbrella body with sub-committees feeding into a national executive, comparing the approach to how the IFA, IBEC and ICTU operate in their own sectors. He argues this would give the industry more weight in talks with government and at EU level and save the Department from having to deal with a long list of separate groups on the same issues. Alongside this, he wants government to review funding for representative bodies and extend support to groups not currently getting any help with running costs or staff.

Other Matters Raised

Several narrower but pointed issues came up in Mulvey’s harbour visits.

The Clogherhead Fishermen’s Co-Operative raised concerns about prawn quotas, which are down 15 percent since Brexit, while noting that the UK, despite getting a bigger quota, doesn’t fish all of it. They also flagged worries about offshore wind farms being sited on prime prawn grounds without enough oversight.

On pelagic quota, the National Inshore Fishermen’s Association pushed for a share of the mackerel and herring quota for vessels under 18 metres, arguing the current allocation is concentrated among a small number of large offshore boats. Mulvey stops short of recommending a change here, calling it “a complex issue” better suited to further talks between the sector and the Department.

Bluefin Tuna also came up. Inshore fishermen want access to a dedicated hook-and-line quota, but Ireland currently has no allocation at all, a legacy of not having a commercial track record for the species when EU quotas were first divided up in the late 1990s. Ireland has asked the EU to open talks on this, but other member states are resistant to reopening the allocation system, and any change would need a qualified majority to pass.

On enforcement, Mulvey’s meetings with the SFPA produced a detailed picture of the scale of its work in 2025: 46,000 vessel landings into Ireland, 126 suspected infringements, 2,900 inspections, 2,900 shellfish samples, and 2,300 food safety checks. Some 78 sea-fishery law enforcement cases were opened, and just over 1,100 catch certificates were issued covering close to 30,000 tonnes of exported seafood, with a further 6,200 export consignments certified. Mulvey heard concerns about a backlog of cases awaiting hearing through the courts and recommends moving toward a system of on-the-spot fines for minor breaches, similar to Scotland, to ease pressure on the courts and speed up how cases are dealt with.

What’s Actually New

To be fair to Mulvey, a handful of recommendations do go further than past reviews. Beyond the new department, he raises a specific concern about Ireland’s fisheries team in Brussels: just one fisheries counsellor, one fisheries attaché, two third secretaries, a policy officer, and shared support staff, covering the country’s interests through an EU Presidency term. He says he is “concerned” this is not enough given the scale of the work involved.

The income top-up scheme, while borrowing from existing farming and arts sector models, hasn’t featured strongly in previous fisheries reviews in quite this form. And his direct comparison to Scotland’s faster licensing and fines systems gives officials a concrete external benchmark to work from, rather than a vague call for improvement.

What’s Not New

Set against that, most of the list reads as a re-run of asks that have circulated since at least the 2021 and 2022 Common Fisheries Policy Review Group reports. Reviving the Young Skipper Scheme, cutting grant paperwork, merging representative bodies into one national voice, fast-tracking non-EU work permits, and reforming aquaculture licensing have all appeared, in some form, in earlier rounds of consultation.

The report itself is candid about this pattern. Mulvey records that stakeholders described existing engagement structures as producing “no real definable outcomes,” and that recommendations from past working groups are “not acted upon with any degree of urgency or remain unimplemented.” That is, in effect, the industry’s verdict on the process that produced this report as well as the ones before it.

Where It Goes from Here

The report is addressed to Minister Dooley, but its recommendations touch on multiple departments, including Enterprise, Social Protection, and the wider Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment on marine planning matters. Much of what Mulvey proposes will depend on cross-department cooperation that has proven difficult to secure in the past.

The report was commissioned partly in response to a group set up by Ministers Heydon and Dooley under Food Vision 2030, tasked with building a support framework for the sector following reduced fishing opportunities in 2026. Whether that group, or the broader move toward a Marine-focused ministry, translates the Mulvey findings into anything more lasting than previous reviews remains to be seen.

For now, the sector’s patience with reports that restate known problems without new funding or firm deadlines attached appears to be wearing thin. Mulvey’s own words capture the mood at the harbours he visited: a “profound sense of unease” about the future, with the pressures facing the industry showing “no evidence of relenting.” As he puts it in his closing remarks, fishing “is not just about harvesting fish, it is also about our culture and that of our Gaeltacht’s, our history, a sense of place and the generations of our people who have maintained their livelihood from the sea.”

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Please enter a comment.
Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email address.

The Skipper Windy Map
The Skipper Tide Checker

Loading tide data...

The Skipper Weather Station

Loading weather data...