Advertise Subscribe
BIM FLAG Southwest: You've got the idea. We've got the funding. Let's talk. Application workshop, Rose Hotel Tralee, 25 November 2026
BIM FLAG Southwest: You've got the idea. We've got the funding. Let's talk. Application workshop, Rose Hotel Tralee, 25 November 2026

News Hub / Ireland

Killybegs Pair Put New Bycatch Excluder to the Test

Share this article
The Killybegs pair trawlers Olgarry and Pacelli, which carried out the first sea trial of the new pelagic bycatch excluder in September. Photo: BIM

The Killybegs pair trawlers Olgarry and ⁠​​​​​​​‌‌‌​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌​​​​​‌​​​‌‌​​‌​⁠Pacelli, which carried out the first sea trial of the new pelagic bycatch excluder in September. Photo: BIM

The Irish pelagic fleet is not waiting for a bycatch problem before it acts. In September the Killybegs pair trawlers Olgarry and Pacelli spent a week off the west and south coasts testing a new excluder designed to let large fish such as bluefin tuna and sharks escape alive from the trawl, while keeping mackerel, horse mackerel (scad), blue whiting and boarfish in the net.

Large fish are rarely caught in pelagic trawls, but when they are, they cause real trouble on deck and when the catch is being pumped and transferred. With bluefin and shark numbers recovering in Irish waters, skippers and scientists expect such encounters to become more frequent. The aim is to have a practical answer ready before that happens.

In a pelagic fishery the balance is simple to state and hard to strike: keep the fish the boat is targeting and has quota for, and let go what it does not want. Get it wrong one way and good fish are lost; get it wrong the other way and an unwanted species can become a choke, using up a small allowance and tying up a boat, or even closing a fishery, while quota for the main species is still unfished. An excluder that lets large non-target fish out before they reach the brailer, and holds on to the catch, helps keep the fleet at sea.

Built in Killybegs, Backed Across the Industry

The trial is a joint effort, and it began with the industry. The Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation first proposed it as part of its work as a partner in CIBBRiNA, an EU project on reducing the bycatch of sensitive species, and then brought it to the Irish Fisheries Science Research Partnership, which brings fishermen and scientists together, to develop it nationally. Alongside the KFO, it involves BIM, the Marine Institute and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, with the support of the Irish Fish Producers’ Organisation and the Irish South and East and Irish South and West Fish Producers’ Organisations.

Minister of State Timmy Dooley approved the trial after it was discussed at the Quota Management Advisory Committee, and set aside a scientific quota of 400 tonnes of boarfish to make it possible. The Olgarry and Pacelli were the pair selected, in June.

The excluder itself was made by KT Nets in Killybegs, which won the contract through a BIM tender. Its design was worked out at meetings in Killybegs in July and August between Donald John (DJ) Maclean of KT Nets, the man behind the design, the Olgarry’s skipper and mate, and gear and fisheries scientists from BIM, the KFO and the Marine Institute.

Bycatch excluder net section laid out in the KT Nets loft, Killybegs
The excluder section laid out in the KT Nets loft in Killybegs before the trial. Photo: BIM

It fits into a section of trawl about 20 metres long, just ahead of the brailer. Inside is a flexible grid and a guiding ramp. Small fish pass through the grid and on into the brailer; anything too big to get through is steered towards an escape opening and out of the net. It is designed to work on single and pair trawlers alike.

Five Hauls, Five Cameras

The excluder was fitted to the Olgarry, skippered by Garry McGing with his mate Marty McGing, fishing with Michael Callaghan’s Pacelli between 8 and 14 September. A planned test tow in Donegal Bay was called off because of the weather, so the pair steamed south to the boarfish grounds.

They made five hauls, four with the excluder in place and one without it for comparison, starting small and building up, from about 2 tonnes of boarfish in the first tow to 60 tonnes in the last. Four CatchCam underwater cameras and a GoPro recorded what happened inside and around the device on every tow.

The trial team fitting an underwater camera to the net on deck during the September sea trial.
The trial team fitting an underwater camera to the net on deck during the September sea trial. Photo: BIM

The first result is the one that matters ⁠​​​​​​​‌‌‌​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌​​​​​‌​​​‌‌​​‌​⁠most to skippers. The excluder caused no problems shooting or hauling, the crew noticed no difference in handling the gear, and the net wound on and off the net drum as normal. The footage showed the trawl opening properly and holding its shape. Earlier excluder designs used elsewhere have often fallen down on exactly this point.

Underwater camera view of the excluder section in a pelagic trawl
An underwater camera view of the excluder section during a tow. Photo: BIM

Learning From the Footage

The cameras also showed what still needs work. Where the grid met the ramp, it bowed into an arch, leaving a gap. Boarfish, which the footage showed to be weak swimmers carried along by the flow of water, were swept into that gap and out through the escape opening in larger numbers than the team wanted.

The footage also revealed something useful about the fish themselves. Horse mackerel swam strongly against the current and were far more likely to pass through the grid and stay in the catch. And the boarfish that did escape swam away freely, with no visible loss of scales.

Boarfish swimming out through the excluder escape opening
Boarfish leaving through the escape opening, the footage that showed the team what to change. Photo: BIM

Rather than wait for the net yard, the crew and scientists set about solving the problem on deck between tows, to cut down the unwanted escapes, with DJ Maclean guiding them from ashore throughout the trip. Footage from each tow was sent to him, and Marty McGing talked through every modification with him by phone. Between them they hung heavy chain on the lower edge of the grid to hold it down on the ramp, tied nine small floats under the ramp to lift it, sewed up about a metre of the escape opening to slow the water running through it, and rigged rubber bungees to draw the grid and ramp together.

Crew and the trial team working on the net on deck between tows.
Crew and the trial team working on the net on deck between tows. Photo: BIM

Each fix improved the excluder’s shape, though the boarfish losses were still higher than the team wanted. That is what a first trial is for. No one had measured boarfish losses through an excluder like this before, so there was no figure to judge them against; this trial sets the benchmark that later versions will be measured by. A working deck only allows so much, so the team brought the excluder home to finish the job properly. It is now back in the KT Nets loft, being reworked with a narrower grid, more weight and a smaller escape opening: lessons taken straight from the footage.

Edward Farrell of the KFO said the project showed what the industry can do when it takes the lead. “The excluder project has shown the value of the industry taking the initiative and leading the development of practical solutions to applied problems. Without the valuable input of DJ in KT and many of the KFO members, but particularly Marty McGing, we wouldn’t have got near this stage of progress yet. It’s also highlighted how well the industry, BIM, the MI and DAFM can work together when there is some joined up thinking and a common goal. Hopefully we can apply the same approach in future projects.”

Back to Sea Before the Year Is Out

Further sea trials are planned before the end of the year. The boarfish shoals met in September were small; by November they are much denser, which will test whether the grid clogs when a big shoal goes into the net. The KFO sees this trial as the first step, with the device to be refined and fine-tuned over the next few years. Once a design is proven, the team expects the same principles to work across a range of pelagic fisheries and target species.

Martin Oliver of BIM said the cameras were central to the work. “We are fortunate to have an array of underwater cameras such as the CatchCams and GoPro. The underwater footage provides valuable information on fish behaviour and the performance of the excluder. Modifications currently being made to the excluder will be examined using underwater cameras in future work.”

The trial is funded by the Irish Government and part-financed by the European Union through the EMFAF programme 2021 to 2027. BIM’s full progress report, Pelagic Bycatch Excluder Trial: Progress Report (October 2026), is available on bim.ie.

The Trial at a Glance

  • Vessels: MFV Olgarry SO591 (skipper Garry McGing) and MFV Pacelli D383 (skipper Michael Callaghan), Killybegs
  • When and where: 8 to 14 September 2026, off the west and south coasts
  • The device: a flexible grid and guiding ramp in a 20 m section of trawl ahead of the brailer, made by KT Nets, Killybegs
  • Hauls: five (four with the excluder, one without), from about 2 t to 60 t of boarfish
  • Cameras: four CatchCams and a GoPro
  • Scientific quota: 400 t of boarfish, approved by Minister of State Timmy Dooley
  • Partners: KFO (which proposed the trial through the EU CIBBRiNA project), BIM, Marine Institute, DAFM; developed through the IFSRP; supported by the IFPO, IS&EFPO and IS&WFPO
  • Next: further sea trials on denser boarfish shoals before the end of 2026

Read more: Better 2027 possible for Irish & UK pelagic fishing fleet if the coastal states stick to the science

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Please enter a comment.
Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email address.

The Skipper Windy Map
The Skipper Tide Checker

Loading tide data...

The Skipper Weather Station

Loading weather data...