“Caught Less, Paid More, Cut Hardest” – 2025 Fish Prices Mask Falling Catches
BIM’s Business of Seafood 2025 reads as a steady year. Beneath the headline value sits a fleet catching less fish, leaning on two species, and walking into the deepest quota cut it has ever faced.
Read on its own, the 2025 scorecard for Irish fishing looks like a sector that held the line. The value of landings rose 7 per cent to EUR 346 million. Mackerel reclaimed top spot, crab climbed, and the published verdict from Bord Iascaigh Mhara is a relatively stable performance. The trouble is that the stability was bought almost entirely with price rather than fish, and the bill for that arrangement falls due in 2026.
Behind the rising value line sits a blunt fact the report does not soften. Total landed volume fell by 11 per cent. Irish boats brought home less fish in 2025 than the year before, and the only reason the value points upward is that buyers paid more for what little crossed the quay. BIM is plain about the mechanism, pointing to the growing influence of price in determining returns for the fleet. Take the price effect away and the catching sector did not grow. It shrank and was paid more for shrinking.
THE PRICE ILLUSION
Stronger prices, smaller catch
The arithmetic of 2025 rewarded scarcity. Tight global supply and continued demand for a narrow band of high value species pushed prices up fast enough to mask the fall in tonnage. Mackerel was the most valuable species at EUR 91 million, its value up 11 per cent on the back of constrained international supply. Crab had a strong year, with landed value rising 22 per cent to EUR 25 million. On paper this is a sector in good health. In the hold, the story is one of less fish landed and a growing dependence on whatever the market happens to be willing to pay.
That dependence is the quiet warning running through the fisheries chapter. BIM notes that the widening gap between volume and value reflects a growing reliance on a small number of high value species and favourable market conditions. The agency is careful to add that while this delivered strong returns in 2025, it also leaves the sector more exposed. A fall in global prices, particularly for mackerel or Dublin Bay prawn, or a further climb in operating costs, could stress profit margins quickly. The report does not pretend the favourable conditions are guaranteed to last.
Two species carrying the fleet
Concentration is the structural weakness the figures expose. Mackerel at EUR 91 million and Dublin Bay prawn at EUR 71 million together accounted for roughly 47 per cent of all Irish landed value in 2025. A sector that earns nearly half its income from two stocks is a sector with very little room to absorb a shock to either. And the prawn figure is not as reassuring as its rank suggests. Dublin Bay prawn held second place by value, but its value fell 5 per cent year on year even as it remained a mainstay of the southern and Irish Sea fleets.
Some of the eye-catching growth percentages should be read with caution rather than celebration. Horse mackerel value rose 1,398 per cent, but that reflects recovery from an almost negligible base rather than any real surge in fortune. Stripped of the statistical noise, the picture is consistent. A handful of pelagic and shellfish stocks did the heavy lifting, while much of the rest of the list fell, with haddock down 19 per cent, whelk down 16 per cent and sprat down 68 per cent.
A sector that earns nearly half its income from two stocks has very little room to absorb a shock to either.
There is a further detail the headline value conceals. While Irish landings rose 7 per cent, the value of non-Irish landings into Irish ports rose 30 per cent to EUR 178 million. At Castletownbere, foreign vessels now account for 77 per cent of landed value. The throughput keeping some of the country’s largest ports busy is increasingly not coming from the Irish fleet at all, a point worth holding in mind when the catching sector’s own quota is about to contract.
THE 2026 RECKONING
The deepest cut on record
If 2025 was a year held together by price, 2026 removes the thing the fleet cannot control more of, which is fish to catch. BIM does not hedge its language here. Quota allocations for 2026 represent the most severe reductions ever faced by the Irish fleet. Total quota volume will fall by 28 per cent to 131,150 tonnes, with the estimated value of that quota declining 26 per cent to EUR 220 million. Quotas were first introduced into European fisheries in 1982, and in the four decades since, the Irish fleet has not faced a cut on this scale.

Source: BIM, Business of Seafood 2025. 2025 quota comparators are derived from the stated single-year percentage changes; some figures rounded.
The single year movement is stark. The estimated value of available quota falls by around EUR 77 million between 2025 and 2026. That is not a market price softening that might reverse next season. It is a hard administrative reduction in how much fish the fleet is legally permitted to land, and it lands on a cost base that the report expects to remain high, with fuel singled out as a continuing pressure.
Pelagic stocks take the heaviest blow
The pelagic fleet, which delivered the most valuable single species of 2025, is the segment hit hardest in 2026. Pelagic quota volume falls 33 per cent and pelagic quota value falls 37 per cent, a reduction of roughly EUR 55 million in a single year. The driver is mackerel. The mackerel quota for areas VI and VII is cut by 53 per cent to 18,705 tonnes. The stock that carried the fleet through 2025 is being more than halved for 2026, which is the central contradiction of this report. The fleet’s greatest strength last year is its greatest exposure this year.
Blue whiting compounds the pressure, with its quota down 41 per cent to 30,188 tonnes. Boarfish falls 22 per cent to 20,537 tonnes. There are isolated bright spots in the pelagic table, with the albacore allocation up 8 per cent and herring in areas I and II up 33 per cent, but these are small tonnages set against the collapse in the two stocks that underpin pelagic earnings. For the larger pelagic vessels working out of Killybegs and the northwest, the 2026 allocation represents a fundamental reduction in the year’s available business.
The stock that carried the fleet through 2025 is being more than halved for 2026.
Whitefish and the Celtic Sea
The demersal sector offers no shelter. Whitefish quotas have been reduced across all areas, and some of the individual cuts are severe enough to question the viability of targeting particular stocks at all. In Area VII, the cod quota for divisions VIIb to VIIk falls 92 per cent to just 27 tonnes, saithe falls 94 per cent to 41 tonnes, and haddock in VIIa falls 69 per cent. In the northwest grounds of Area VI, the cod allocation for VIa falls 76 per cent and saithe falls 78 per cent. These are not trims. For several traditional whitefish stocks, the 2026 quota is now so small that it functions mainly as an unavoidable bycatch constraint on other fisheries.
Taken at the level of whole sea areas, the Celtic Sea demersal stocks of Area VII fall 8 per cent in volume and 16 per cent in value, to EUR 96 million. Area VI demersal stocks fall 13 per cent in volume and 9 per cent in value. The combined Area VI and VII demersal category, which includes deepwater and shark species, falls 21 per cent in volume. Across the demersal fleet the message is uniform. There will be less to catch, and the species mix that remains is weighted toward the lower value end of the table.
THE WIDER SQUEEZE
Costs high, alternatives thin
The cost side of the ledger is moving the wrong way at the same time. BIM warns that almost every part of the catching sector will face a more constrained operating environment in 2026, with less quota available and operating costs remaining high, fuel most of all. A vessel with a smaller allocation still carries broadly the same fixed costs of crew, insurance, gear and finance, so a 28 per cent cut in volume does not mean a 28 per cent cut in the cost of going to sea. The squeeze on margins is sharper than the headline percentages suggest.
The exposure is not spread evenly. Direct seafood employment stood at 7,509, around 6 per cent of coastal employment, and it is concentrated in the communities most reliant on the pelagic stocks now being cut. The northern region around Killybegs, home to the bulk of the large pelagic fleet, carries the highest dependence of any region. A 53 per cent mackerel cut and a 41 per cent blue whiting cut do not land on an abstract national total. They land on a handful of ports and the families tied to them, where little alternative work exists to absorb the shock.
Nor can the fleet easily lean on the rest of the seafood economy to carry it through. The processing figures relate to 2024 rather than 2025, and even then, growth was modest, with turnover up 2 per cent and employment up 3 per cent. Processors are already being told to expect domestic supply to tighten as the 2026 cuts take effect, which is why BIM expects them to rely increasingly on imported raw material. That keeps factories running but puts no more fish into Irish nets. Aquaculture offers no offset either, its value flat in 2025 and its employment down 7 per cent. The sector’s reported gross domestic product rose 6 per cent to EUR 1.31 billion, but that total is carried by consumption and trade, not by the boats. The part of the economy the fishermen actually control is the part now contracting fastest.
THE VIEW FROM BIM
Donnelly: real challenges, cautious optimism
BIM did not let the figures speak alone. Richard Donnelly, chief executive of Bord Iascaigh Mhara, framed the year as one of resilience set against mounting difficulty, acknowledging the scale of what is coming while pointing to reasons the sector should not lose heart.
Donnelly said the report highlights a sector operating in an increasingly difficult trading environment, with significant quota reductions and ongoing cost pressures creating real challenges for fishing, aquaculture and processing businesses. To that extent the chief executive and the data agree. Where the framing turns is in what comes next. There are, he said, important grounds for cautious optimism, citing strong global demand, record export performance and continued growth in domestic consumption as proof of the enduring value of Irish seafood, alongside investment in processing capacity and the rapid development of the aquatech sector.
There are important grounds for cautious optimism. Richard Donnelly, BIM
On the year ahead, Donnelly said the priority now is to support the industry in adapting to reduced domestic supply while continuing to build competitiveness, innovation and market reach, adding that the resilience shown to date gives confidence that the sector can navigate the period ahead. It is a measured statement, and a fair one as far as the wider seafood economy is concerned. The caution it carries should not be lost, however. Most of the optimism rests on parts of the chain that sit downstream of the boats, namely trade, processing, aquatech and the dinner plate, while the catching sector itself is the link being squeezed hardest.
What the numbers add up to
Set side by side, the two halves of this report tell a single story. In 2025 the catching sector caught less and was rescued by price. In 2026 it will be permitted to catch far less still, with its most valuable stock more than halved and its cost base holding firm. The favourable market conditions that papered over the 11 per cent volume fall in 2025 are exactly the conditions BIM cannot guarantee will hold, and even if prices stay strong, there will simply be far fewer tonnes to sell at them.
One point the headline figures can blur is worth stating plainly. The EUR 220 million quota value and the EUR 346 million landings value are not the same measure and should not be read as a straight subtraction. A large share of landed value comes from non-quota shellfish such as crab, shrimp and lobster, which the cuts do not touch, and that cushions total fleet earnings. It does nothing, though, for the pelagic and whitefish operators whose entire business is built on the stocks now being cut. They will feel 2026 first and hardest.
Investment, innovation and productivity, the levers Donnelly points to, are real and matter over time. They will not replace some 50,000 tonnes of quota in a single season. On BIM’s own numbers, 2026 is the hardest year the Irish catching sector has faced in the four decades since quotas began, and the strong 2025 value figure is the last good number before the squeeze arrives in full.
Full report available at https://bim.ie/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Business-of-Seafood-2025.pdf
Source: Bord Iascaigh Mhara, Business of Seafood 2025, in collaboration with the Sea-Fisheries Protection Authority.


